[mailhist-discuss] *** NOTE WELL *** Mailing List Participation Policies
dhc at dcrocker.net
Fri Mar 16 13:51:57 PDT 2012
Welcome to the EmailHistory.org discussion list!
Discussions about history often become controversial and heated. Controversy can
be healthy. Heat rarely is. When it occurs with any regularity, it tends to
reduce participation by otherwise-valuable representatives of the community.
Consequently this site and its discussion venues will conform to the basic
open-participation policies established in the emailhistory.org, which has a
long history of
process and culture that is based on open participation. The core requirement is
that participants must strive to be constructive.
This is not an emailhistory.org site or activity, but it is borrowing from
culture and policies.
This obviously means maintaining a professional demeanor, but it also means
staying within scope. Failure in either produces a distracted and likely hostile
environment. Which winds up meaning that the discussion venue discourages
participation and fails to move forward.
Anyone can have a bad day and fail in one way or the other.
Patterns of failure are another matter, and is where the Site Management, must act.
Some discussion venues can be managed loosely because they're on relatively
non-controversial subject matter, however the basic assumption for open
discussion venues on this site is that they need close attention to participant
This notice serves to ensure that participants are aware of the rules governing
participation and enforcement procedures.
Here is the formal emailhistory.org documentation for procedures to enforce
RFC 2418: emailhistory.org Working Group Guidelines and Procedures
> 3.3 Session Management
> To facilitate making forward
> progress, a Working Group Chair may wish to decide to reject
> or defer the input from a member, based upon the following > criteria:
> The input pertains to a topic that already has been resolved
> and is redundant with information previously available;
> The input is new and pertains to a topic that has already
> been resolved, but it is felt to be of minor import to the
> existing decision;
> The input pertains to a topic that the working group
> has not yet opened for discussion; or
> The input is outside of the scope of the working group
RFC 3934 as it amends RFC 2418 section 3.2
> As in face-to-face sessions, occasionally one or more
> individuals may engage in behavior on a mailing list that, in
> the opinion of the WG chair, is disruptive to the WG process.
> Unless the disruptive behavior is severe enough that it must be
> stopped immediately, the WG chair should attempt to discourage
> the disruptive behavior by communicating directly with the
> offending individual. If the behavior persists, the WG chair
> should send at least one public warning on the WG mailing list.
> As a last resort and typically after one or more explicit
> warnings and consultation with the responsible Area Director,
> the WG chair may suspend the mailing list posting privileges of
> the disruptive individual for a period of not more than 30 days...
Site Management will be actively managing groups' conduct with respect to any
egregious behavior or any tendency towards participation that qualifies under
the criteria listed under RFC 2418, Section 3.2 (as amended) or Section 3.3, and
will use the enforcement procedures defined in RFC 3934 if necessary.
Intellectual Property Policies
Any submission of materials to the emailhistory.org site or a mailing list
operated through emailhistory.org intended by the Contributor for publication as
all or part of a document produced through the emailhistory.org activities and
any statement made within the context of an emailhistory.org activity is
considered an "emailhistory.org Contribution". Such statements include oral
statements in emailhistory.org sessions, as well as written and electronic
communications made at any time or place, which are addressed to:
The emailhistory.org activity
Any emailhistory.org mailing list, including the discuss at emailhistory.org
list itself, any working group or design team list that is part of
emailhistory.org, or any other list functioning under emailhistory.org auspices
Any emailhistory.org working group or portion thereof
All emailhistory.org Contributions are subject to the rules of RFC 5378 and RFC
3979 (updated by RFC 4879).
Statements made outside of a formal emailhistory.org activity, mailing list or
other function, that are clearly not intended to be input to an emailhistory.org
activity, group or function, are not emailhistory.org Contributions in the
context of this notice.
Please consult RFC 5378 and RFC 3979 for details.
A participant in any emailhistory.org activity is deemed to accept all
emailhistory.org rules of process, as documented in Best Current Practices RFCs
and IESG Statements.
A participant in any emailhistory.org activity acknowledges that written, audio
and video records of meetings may be made and may be available to the public.
More information about the mailhist-discuss